Josh Allen’s Recurring Nightmare: Thin Margins, Crushing Pressure, and the Somatic Reset He Needs Now.
Football’s postseason is ruthless in the way it exposes truth.
Over the long weekend, three of the five marquee games—spanning the NFL divisional round and the CFP National Championship—ended on interceptions. Not blown coverages. Not schematic failures. Turnovers. Josh Allen’s overtime pick against Denver. Caleb Williams’ giveaway to the Rams. Carson Beck’s final desperation throw snagged to seal an Indiana title.
These weren’t random mistakes. They were pressure fractures.
When margins compress and seasons hang on a single decision, performance stops being about talent and starts being about access—access to clarity, access to restraint, access to a nervous system that can stay regulated when everything inside is screaming to force an outcome.
No one embodies this reality more starkly than Josh Allen.
A Brutal Night and a Familiar Ending
Josh Allen’s season ended Saturday night the way too many of his seasons have ended: painfully, publicly, and with him at the center of the collapse.
Buffalo lost to Denver 33–30 in overtime. Allen—an eight-year veteran and reigning NFL MVP—turned the ball over four times. Two interceptions. Two fumbles. One of those fumbles came with three seconds left in the first half on Buffalo’s own side of the field, handing Denver a free field goal before the locker room. Another missed opportunity came later—a wide-open flag route to the tight end that would have ended the game outright. Seven points left on the field, minimum.
In overtime, Allen again got the ball with a chance to win. And again, it ended with him coming up short—an interception to Ja'Quan McMillian on a deep throw to Brandin Cooks that sparked endless debate over whether it should have been ruled down by contact, but the call stood, and the Broncos marched for the walk-off field goal.
After the game, Allen was emotional, fighting tears as he took responsibility.
“I feel like I let my teammates down tonight. You can’t win with five turnovers. If you shoot yourself in the foot like that, you don’t deserve to win the football game.”
Teammates rushed to defend him. And they’re not wrong. Allen is the reason Buffalo is relevant year after year. He has dragged imperfect rosters further than they likely should have gone. He has been heroic—often superhuman—for long stretches of his career.
But that defense only goes so far.
If Allen wants to be the best, not just statistically but historically, he has to be steady when the gap between capacity and demand narrows. And that’s where the pattern becomes impossible to ignore. He’s now 0–7 in overtime games career-wide, including 0–3 in playoff overtimes. Eight seasons. Seven playoff appearances. Two AFC Championship Games. Zero Super Bowls.
This isn’t one bad night. It’s a pattern of breakdown under pressure.
Josh Allen’s missed touchdown opportunity to win the game.
The Performance Gap No One Wants to Name
The “he’s the only reason they’re contenders” argument is emotionally understandable, but incomplete.
Yes, Allen raises Buffalo’s ceiling. But championships are decided on the field in the toughest moments. MVPs don’t just expand what’s possible; they stabilize what’s inevitable. And right now, Allen’s performance floor in the biggest moments is too volatile. He can’t be the league’s most valuable player if, year after year, his decision-making and play-making degrade precisely when the game demands its cleanest execution.
Even if Buffalo wins that game on a different bounce or a different call, the performance gap remains. The issue isn’t outcomes alone; it’s access. And access is a nervous-system problem before it’s ever a football problem.
The Nervous System Under Playoff Pressure
Elite performance lives downstream of regulation.
When an athlete is regulated, information processing is fast, perception is wide, and decision-making is economical. When the nervous system tips into threat—sympathetic overdrive and fight, flight, freeze, and fawn responses—those same skills narrow. Vision tunnels. Timing rushes. Force replaces feel.
The playoffs are not just louder, faster versions of the regular season. They are qualitatively different environments. Every snap carries consequence. Every mistake echoes backward through years of near-misses. And the nervous system keeps score.
By the time Allen steps into another overtime, he isn’t just playing Denver. He’s carrying eight seasons of unfinished stress: previous interceptions, previous collapses, previous press conferences where he took the blame. That cumulative load doesn’t disappear because he watches more film or tightens his mechanics. It lives in the body.
This is how performance blocks form. Not from lack of preparation, but from too much unprocessed experience.
Where Allen Goes From Here: Processing, Not Forcing
Coming up short after eight consecutive seasons with real opportunity creates a massive somatic burden. And that burden shows up exactly where Allen struggles most: in tight moments where patience, precision, and restraint matter more than raw ability.
The answer is not trying harder. The answer is processing.
If Allen is serious about closing this gap, one tool should be non-negotiable: brainspotting.
Brainspotting works directly with the subcortical brain—the same region responsible for threat detection, habit loops, and stress memory. It allows athletes to process unresolved emotional and physiological load without having to relive it cognitively. For quarterbacks, this matters. You can’t think your way out of a nervous-system problem.
Specific moments, like the missed flag route, the halftime fumble, and the overtime interception, aren’t just memories; they’re stored states. Until they’re processed, the nervous system will anticipate them repeating. This anticipation under pressure is how elite players lose access to their best decisions.
Brainspotting diffuses that stored charge. Athletes across sports—from MLB shortstops to Olympic skiers—have used it to dissolve blocks like the yips, slumps, and freezing in high-stakes spots. It targets the exact subcortical charge that keeps replaying the same errors in crunch time. But it can’t stand alone.
The Somatic Reset: Rebuilding Access Under Pressure
To truly change the pattern, brainspotting should be paired with other body-based practices that rebuild regulation under stress.
Performance yoga restores trust in the body while introducing controlled instability. It trains interoception, proprioception, and adaptability. Being able to stay calm in the face of unfamiliar movement and stimuli goes a long way for a quarterback whose game depends on rhythm and clarity amid chaos. Breath-guided, dynamic flows mimic the game's unpredictability, teaching the nervous system to calmly work with internal and external tension rather than forcing through it.
Mindfulness develops awareness without attachment. It’s not about positivity or confidence. It’s about training attention to notice tightening, rushing, or forcing as it happens and choose differently before the mistake compounds. Daily body scans while staying neutral to what he observes could help Allen catch rising tension in real time—tight grip before a throw, shallow breath in the huddle—and intervene with calm presence.
Breathwork is the fastest lever of all. It directly shifts the autonomic state. Under pressure, Allen doesn’t need hype; he needs access to parasympathetic braking. Techniques like the physiological sigh (double inhale through the nose, one long exhale), box breathing (inhale for 4, hold for 4, exhale for 4, hold for 4), and 4-7-8 breathing (inhale for 4, hold for 7, exhale for 8) create a mid-game reset button. Breath isn’t just air; it’s the quickest path to shifting from sympathetic overdrive, like rushed or forced decisions, to the calm where timing, touch, and discernment live.
These tools don’t erase mistakes. They complete stress cycles. And when stress cycles complete, the nervous system stops dragging the past into the present. That’s the difference between learning and repeating.
Thin Margins Demand Deeper Work
The playoffs expose what the regular season can conceal. They don’t just test toughness or leadership. They test whether an athlete has metabolized their own history or if they’re still carrying it. Josh Allen’s career is not a failure, but it’s stalled at a familiar edge.
The margins are thin, and the pressure is immense. Talent alone no longer separates outcomes at the highest levels. That means that the next step isn’t technical or mechanical. It’s somatic.
If Allen is willing to do the deeper work of processing what his body has been holding for nearly a decade, this story doesn’t have to keep ending the same way. And if he doesn’t? The pattern will keep finishing the season for him.
—
If you’re an athlete staring down your own pattern of big-moment falters or a coach ready to build teams that thrive under pressure, reach out. I’ve guided pros across sports through this exact somatic reset, turning heartbreak into unbreakable resilience. Let’s clear the load and unlock what’s next.
Metta,
Drewsome.
