Across youth, collegiate, and professional sports, we’re becoming increasingly sophisticated at identifying athletic talent, measuring performance, and creating opportunities for athletes to advance. Young athletes have access to specialized coaching, advanced training facilities, performance technology, recruiting platforms, and competitive opportunities that previous generations could hardly have imagined. Yet despite these advancements, I see a growing disconnect between the level of athletic ability young people are developing and their readiness to navigate the environments they’re working so hard to enter.
For more than 15 years, I’ve worked with athletes across professional leagues, Division I programs, and elite developmental environments. One of the patterns I’ve encountered repeatedly is that exceptional athletic ability doesn’t necessarily translate into the capacity to perform consistently as expectations, responsibilities, and competitive demands increase. An athlete can dominate at the high school or club level, earn national recognition, and receive substantial recruiting interest while remaining underdeveloped in areas that become increasingly important at the next level.
Part of the challenge is that success itself can conceal developmental gaps. When an athlete consistently outperforms the competition, their physical gifts and technical abilities can compensate for weaknesses in self-awareness, emotional regulation, adaptability, decision-making, and their ability to navigate adversity. They may rarely experience extended periods of poor performance, reduced playing time, meaningful criticism, or the uncertainty of not knowing where they stand. The adults surrounding them may interpret their continued success as evidence that their development is progressing appropriately, without examining the broader capacities that will eventually be required of them.
This creates an interesting paradox. The very success that opens doors for young athletes can also limit their exposure to the experiences that help them develop the resilience, flexibility, and internal resources necessary to sustain that success. When the path has been relatively linear, athletes may arrive at the next level having accomplished nearly everything asked of them without having developed the capacity to navigate circumstances in which their effort, talent, and preparation no longer produce the outcomes they’ve come to expect.
The Changing Landscape of Collegiate Athletics
These developmental gaps are becoming increasingly consequential as the business of collegiate athletics continues to evolve. NIL opportunities, revenue sharing, transfer activity, roster management, and heightened competitive expectations have fundamentally changed the environment many young athletes are entering, particularly within marquee Division I sports.
College athletics has always involved competition, financial interests, and pressure to win. What’s changing is the speed and scale at which athletes are being evaluated, acquired, compensated, and replaced. Coaches and programs are operating within increasingly transactional systems, where immediate contributions can carry significant value and the patience required for long-term development may be difficult to sustain.
I see the consequences of this regularly in my work. Athletes who were dominant throughout high school receive substantial financial opportunities to compete at major Division I programs, only to experience significant performance declines after arriving. Some struggle to adjust to the level of competition or the expectations placed upon them. Others find themselves in environments where individualized development receives far less attention than they anticipated. As performance deteriorates, the effects often extend beyond athletics, influencing sleep, emotional well-being, academic responsibilities, relationships, and an athlete’s broader sense of identity.
These experiences are not always the result of inadequate coaching or insufficient effort. They’re often the product of several interacting factors, including developmental gaps that existed before college, the demands of an unfamiliar environment, and institutional systems that may be better equipped to recruit and evaluate talent than to develop the whole person behind it.
There are certainly collegiate coaches and programs doing exceptional developmental work, and that deserves recognition. However, we also need to acknowledge the growing tension between the immediate competitive value of an athlete and the longer-term investment required to develop that individual. A program can place substantial financial value on an athlete’s ability without making an equivalent investment in their capacity to sustain and expand that ability.
You can buy talent. You have to develop capacity.
For families navigating recruiting, this distinction is becoming increasingly important. Receiving an offer from a prestigious program, securing a significant financial package, or earning a place on a nationally recognized roster can represent a tremendous accomplishment. None of those outcomes, however, guarantees that the environment will provide the developmental support an athlete needs, or that the athlete is prepared to navigate the demands they’ll encounter.
When the Next Level Reveals What’s Missing
As athletes advance, the conditions surrounding performance change. The competition becomes more sophisticated, the margins for error narrow, and the demands on attention, decision-making, emotional regulation, and recovery increase. Athletes may encounter coaching philosophies they’ve never experienced, teammates who are equally or more talented, reduced roles, unfamiliar expectations, and periods when their previous approaches no longer produce the same results.
For an athlete whose identity has been built largely around being exceptional at their sport, these transitions can be particularly difficult. Someone who has always been the best player on the field may suddenly become one of many talented athletes competing for limited opportunities. Someone who has received consistent recognition and reinforcement may struggle when that attention disappears. An athlete who has relied on physical dominance may discover that their competitive advantage is no longer sufficient to overcome gaps in other areas of performance.
Research on athletic identity supports the importance of looking beyond athletic achievement when evaluating developmental readiness. A 2023 systematic review examining 54 studies on athletic identity highlighted how a strong, exclusive identification with the athlete role can complicate academic engagement, personal development, and adjustment during major transitions. The research also emphasized that identity evolves throughout an athletic career, reinforcing the value of helping young people develop a broader sense of themselves before their circumstances change.
The resulting challenges can become self-reinforcing. An athlete begins struggling, becomes increasingly concerned about their performance, and directs more attention and energy toward trying to regain control. Heightened physiological arousal, frustration, and self-consciousness can interfere with perception, decision-making, coordination, and execution. As those difficulties continue, the athlete may begin questioning their abilities, their future, and eventually their value beyond the sport itself.
This is where the distinction between athletic achievement and holistic readiness becomes especially important. Success at one level demonstrates what an athlete has been able to accomplish under a particular set of conditions. It doesn’t necessarily tell us how effectively they’ll respond when those conditions change.
The demands of a new environment can reveal capacities that were never adequately developed, even in athletes who have demonstrated extraordinary discipline, work ethic, and commitment. Pressure doesn’t build character as much as it reveals how effectively an athlete has developed the internal resources to navigate challenging circumstances. These moments can expose important gaps while also creating opportunities for meaningful growth, provided athletes have the awareness, tools, and support to work through them.
What Holistic Readiness Actually Requires
In my work, I approach human performance through four interconnected dimensions of potential: physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual. By spiritual, I’m referring to the dimension of human development concerned with identity, values, purpose, personal agency, and the broader sense of meaning that helps individuals navigate their lives beyond immediate achievements. These dimensions influence one another continuously, and an athlete’s ability to perform is shaped by how effectively they’re developing and integrating all four.
The physical dimension includes strength, conditioning, technical skill, movement quality, recovery, sleep, and the physiological capacities required for competition. The mental dimension encompasses attention, perception, decision-making, adaptability, and the ability to direct cognitive resources effectively. The emotional dimension involves recognizing and regulating emotional experiences, navigating frustration and disappointment, maintaining healthy relationships, and responding constructively to uncertainty. The spiritual dimension provides a foundation for understanding who an athlete is beyond their competitive role and what gives their efforts meaning and direction.
Athletic development tends to concentrate heavily on the physical dimension, with varying levels of attention given to mental skills. Emotional and spiritual development often receive considerably less intentional investment, particularly when an athlete is performing well. Yet these dimensions become increasingly consequential as competitive demands intensify and athletes encounter circumstances they cannot fully control.
Holistic readiness involves developing the capacity to recognize what’s happening internally, regulate physiological and emotional responses, remain engaged with the present moment, make effective decisions, and adapt when circumstances change. It also involves learning how to receive feedback, take responsibility, communicate effectively, maintain relationships, recover from setbacks, and continue developing when progress becomes less predictable.
An athlete’s nervous system plays an important role in this process. Under heightened pressure, physiological arousal can influence attention, perception, cognitive flexibility, and motor execution. Research on attentional control theory helps explain how anxiety can compromise the efficiency of goal-directed attention, increasing the cognitive resources required to perform tasks that might otherwise feel relatively automatic. An athlete may understand exactly what a situation requires and still struggle to access that knowledge or execute a familiar skill when their internal state becomes difficult to manage. Developing greater awareness of these responses, along with the ability to regulate them in real time, creates more favorable conditions for consistent performance across a wider range of circumstances.
Equally important is developing an identity that can withstand changes in athletic status. Young people need opportunities to explore their values, interests, relationships, academic goals, and aspirations beyond competition. Their athletic pursuits can remain deeply meaningful without becoming the sole foundation of how they understand themselves or measure their worth.
This broader development also prepares athletes for the inevitable transitions that extend beyond a competitive season or collegiate career. Injuries, transfers, coaching changes, changes in playing time, and eventually retirement can significantly alter an athlete’s relationship with their sport. The capacities developed through holistic preparation should remain valuable regardless of whether an individual continues competing at the highest level.
Importantly, holistic readiness doesn’t eliminate adversity or guarantee competitive success. Even exceptionally well-developed athletes experience setbacks, periods of poor performance, and difficult transitions. The difference is that they’re better equipped to recognize what’s happening, respond constructively, access appropriate support, and continue developing.
The objective is to expand an athlete’s capacity to navigate a wider range of circumstances, rather than promise control over outcomes that will always involve uncertainty.
Developmental Responsibility Begins Long Before College
One of the most concerning assumptions I encounter is that young athletes can concentrate primarily on technical and physical development throughout their early years, with the expectation that a collegiate program will address everything else once they arrive.
Families invest extraordinary amounts of time, energy, and financial resources into private coaching, travel teams, specialized training, camps, showcases, and recruiting opportunities. These investments can provide meaningful benefits, but they don’t automatically produce comprehensive development. When the majority of attention is directed toward improving athletic ability and increasing exposure, the deeper capacities required to navigate competitive environments can remain largely unaddressed.
As the collegiate landscape becomes increasingly transactional, transferring responsibility for holistic development to the institution an athlete eventually attends becomes a particularly risky strategy. By the time significant performance difficulties emerge, the athlete may already be navigating the combined demands of academic responsibilities, financial expectations, competitive uncertainty, and an unfamiliar social environment.
The years leading up to college offer an enormous opportunity to prepare young people more comprehensively, and the adults surrounding them have considerable influence over how that development unfolds.
For parents, this begins with examining how success is defined and reinforced within the family. When conversations consistently revolve around statistics, rankings, recruiting attention, scholarships, and playing time, athletes may gradually internalize the idea that their value is closely connected to those outcomes. Parents can broaden those conversations by taking an active interest in what their children are learning about themselves, how they’re responding to challenges, what they’re enjoying, and how they’re growing beyond their athletic achievements.
Parents are also part of an athlete’s regulatory environment. The way adults respond to uncertainty, disappointment, and perceived setbacks can influence how young people experience those circumstances. Learning to manage their own anxiety, create space for honest conversations, and support independent decision-making can be just as valuable as helping coordinate training schedules and recruiting opportunities.
For club coaches, the opportunity extends beyond technical instruction and competitive results. Coaches can create environments where athletes learn to receive feedback, navigate frustration, take responsibility, communicate effectively, and adapt to changing roles. They can help young people understand that being challenged, making mistakes, or temporarily struggling doesn’t diminish their value or erase their potential.
This doesn’t mean manufacturing unnecessary adversity or withholding support in the name of building toughness. There’s an important distinction between developmentally productive discomfort and circumstances that create persistent distress or genuine harm. Athletes need opportunities to encounter difficulty, but they also need adults who can recognize when a challenge is becoming overwhelming, when functioning is deteriorating, and when additional professional support may be necessary.
School counselors and administrators have an equally important role, particularly because they’re positioned to support aspects of development that extend beyond athletic participation. They can help student-athletes explore academic interests, personal values, career possibilities, relationships, and the broader life they’re building. They can also encourage families to evaluate collegiate opportunities through a more comprehensive lens, considering developmental fit alongside athletic prestige and financial considerations.
Recruiting offers a particularly clear example of how these responsibilities intersect. Young athletes can become so focused on being selected that they lose sight of their own role in evaluating the opportunities available to them. I often refer to this as pick-me syndrome, where the question of whether a program wants an athlete begins to overshadow whether that program is actually right for them.
This pattern is particularly concerning because the relationship an athlete develops with external validation during recruiting can follow them into college. An athlete who begins measuring their worth through recruiting interest may later measure it through playing time, coaching decisions, financial compensation, or their position on a depth chart. The circumstances change, but the underlying developmental vulnerability remains. Helping young athletes establish a stronger sense of identity, personal agency, and direction before they enter these environments can have implications that extend far beyond the recruiting process itself.
One of the most valuable things adults can do is help athletes establish their own criteria before becoming consumed by the recruiting process. What kind of coaching environment will support their development? What academic opportunities align with their interests? What values matter to them? How important are geography, community, culture, and lifestyle? What kind of person do they want to become during their college years?
These conversations help athletes develop greater agency and approach recruiting as a mutual evaluation process rather than a competition for external validation.
Families should also be asking prospective programs questions that extend beyond scholarships, facilities, and immediate playing opportunities. How does the program develop athletes who aren’t currently contributing? What happens when a player experiences a prolonged performance decline? How are athletes supported through injuries, role changes, and academic difficulties? What resources exist for mental performance, emotional well-being, and development beyond sports? How does the coaching staff communicate with athletes when expectations aren’t being met?
Perhaps most importantly, families should be asking what happens to the athlete who isn’t performing well enough to help a program win today but still has tremendous potential to develop tomorrow. The answers to these questions may reveal more about an athlete’s future developmental environment than a program’s national ranking or recruiting reputation.
Preparing Athletes for More Than the Opportunity
As the demands of competitive sports continue to evolve, our approach to developing young athletes needs to evolve with them. The resources devoted to identifying talent, improving technical skills, and creating recruiting opportunities have expanded considerably, but those investments need to be accompanied by a more intentional commitment to developing the whole person.
This requires us to reconsider what successful athletic development actually looks like. An athlete may be improving statistically, accumulating recognition, and attracting interest from prestigious programs while remaining underprepared for the uncertainty, responsibility, and complexity they’ll encounter as they advance. Another athlete may experience a less linear path, face meaningful challenges, and develop capacities that ultimately support greater adaptability and sustainability over time.
Neither trajectory guarantees future success. What matters is whether development is preparing the athlete to meet increasingly complex demands while maintaining the ability to grow, adapt, and function effectively beyond the sport itself.
For parents, coaches, counselors, and administrators, this means looking beyond what young athletes are accomplishing today and considering what they’re becoming capable of navigating tomorrow. It means recognizing that athletic potential is only one part of a much larger developmental picture, and that the environments we create, the questions we ask, and the standards we reinforce can either support or constrain that development.
We cannot control every challenge an athlete will encounter, and we shouldn’t attempt to remove every obstacle from their path. We can, however, take greater responsibility for helping them develop the internal resources, self-awareness, adaptability, and support systems they’ll need when those challenges arise.
Getting recruited, earning a scholarship, or signing a professional contract can open extraordinary doors. Preparing an athlete to navigate what happens after those doors open is a much larger responsibility, and one that deserves far more attention long before they reach the next level.
—
If you're an athlete, parent, coach, or organizational leader looking to take a more comprehensive approach to performance and development, reach out. Through my work with individual athletes, teams, and organizations, I help identify and address the physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual factors that influence performance, adaptability, and long-term development. Whether you're navigating a specific challenge or looking to build a more intentional approach to developing athletes, I'm happy to hear from you and to explore how we might work together.
Metta,
Drewsome.